Tension is brewing in the American Idol universe, and this time, it’s centered around one of the show’s most celebrated alumni — Carrie Underwood.
Once praised as the shining star born from the Idol stage, Underwood’s recent stint as a judge has sparked sharp division among the fanbase, with some viewers even threatening to abandon the show altogether if she returns next season.
Fans Voice Frustration Over Carrie’s Growing Influence
The controversy, insiders reveal, has been intensifying ever since the show’s first-ever faith-based special aired during Easter weekend — a night that Carrie reportedly championed from behind the scenes.
According to a source speaking to The Sun, some fans were already skeptical about her role on the judging panel, but the Easter event pushed frustrations over the edge.
“I’ve heard people on set say that Carrie’s influence is ruining the legacy of the show. Things started great with her this season but the longer she’s been a judge, the more feathers she has ruffled,” the insider shared.
Behind the scenes, tensions seem equally palpable. While Carrie reportedly has Luke Bryan firmly in her corner — often stepping in to ensure she gets what she needs — not everyone on set has embraced the new direction.
Crew members were said to have expressed discomfort over the three-hour gospel-focused broadcast, feeling it may have strayed from Idol’s broader entertainment mission.
Faith-Based Episode Sparks Ratings Decline
Ratings, too, have reportedly taken a hit. The same insider noted a “significant drop” in viewership following the faith-based episode, an event Carrie was particularly passionate about bringing to life. “It was really important for her for the show to go through with it.
Lionel and Luke were on board, but Carrie was the most vocal about wanting it to make sure it happened.
She felt it was important to have gospel night after moving to LA where she feels she can’t be as open about her religion and beliefs,” they explained.
Divided Reactions Leave Carrie’s Future Uncertain
However, it’s not all criticism. While a vocal group of fans are unhappy with Underwood’s growing influence, others have embraced her presence, praising the show for highlighting faith in a way that resonates with many Americans.
During the special, Carrie delivered a stunning, deeply emotional performance of “How Great Thou Art,” which quickly went viral and garnered international praise.
As of now, it remains uncertain whether Carrie Underwood will continue her judging role into the next season. With contestants recently narrowed down to the final 14 — six of whom were saved by the judges while four were sent home — American Idol’s future looks both exciting and uncertain.
One thing is clear: Carrie’s presence has changed the conversation around the show, for better or for worse.
Be sure to catch up on everything happening with American Idol right now. Come back here often for all American Idol spoilers, news, and updates.
I think Carrie is doing a fantastic job! Although I may not be the most religious person on earth, the one night of faith based show certainly was no big deal and might have made a few people feel better!!
[…] Rumblings from within the crew suggest Underwood’s presence is causing friction, with a few even claiming her influence is “ruining” the show’s long-standing legacy. […]